top of page

Neighbors Protecting Neighbors Since 1894

Rooted on Amherst Island, we offer tailored farm and automobile coverage as Ontario's smallest mutual. Contact claims@amherstislandmutualinsurance.ca.

[1]
Policyholder Owned

No corporate shareholders. Our profits directly benefit our community.

[2]
The Guarantee Fund

Backed by the multi-billion dollar Fire Mutuals Guarantee Fund. Your claims are fully guaranteed.

[3]
True Local Service

No automated phone trees, outsourced agents, or corporate call centers.

Voices of our Community

“The personal touch and local support from Amherst Island Mutual have been a true pillar of our family’s farm life since we first started growing here.”

— Sarah Miller, Stella, Ontario

Stay Informed

Join our community for seasonal updates and expert agricultural insurance tips.

bottom of page